Categories: Local

Utah surrogacy gender discrimination case may be first in the nation

Utah Supreme Court justices will hear arguments Tuesday in a case challenging Utah’s surrogacy laws. The married gay couple’s petition to enter a surrogacy agreement was denied last year by southern Utah’s 5th District Court Judge Jeffery C. Wilcox, who determined he had no choice but to reject the petition “because neither of the legally married intended parents are women.” The couple is now asking Utah’s high court to declare a portion of the state’s surrogacy law unconstitutional as it forbids gay men the right to have biological children through surrogacy.

“As written, [the law] creates two classes of intended parents; one class for married same-sex male couples and another class for married couples where at least one of the intended parents is female,” the couple’s attorney Edwin Wall wrote in a brief filed with the court. “That exclusion violates the due process and equal protection clauses of the U.S. Constitution, as well as the uniform operation of law clause in the Utah Constitution.”

The Utah Attorney General’s office, which typically defends state laws before the court, is not opposing the case. In its own brief, the office agrees that the district court’s order should be reversed and supports a gender-neutral reading of the statutes, the brief from Assistant Solicitor General Brent Burnett said.

“If marriage equality really means what the Supreme Court said it does, then that should mean this gay married male couple should have the same entitlements as others,” Widenar University law professor John Culhane, who frequently writes about legal issues for LGBTQ people, told The Salt Lake Tribune. The equality argument, he added, is one that any state would be hard-pressed to defend against.



Recent Posts

  • Deep Inside Hollywood

Get ready for a Roy Cohn-ucopia

Did you miss the Roy Cohn lesson in queer history class? Do you still not know about the closeted, Trump-mentoring,…

18 mins ago
  • Arts News
  • Local

UMOCA’s 2019 exhibition season expands to Trolley Square, offers LGBTQ teen program

Exhibitions focusing on the long-term effects of American suburban development, a tongue-in-cheek look at self-medication, enhanced residency opportunities for Utah…

2 hours ago
  • Local
  • Save The Date

Hotel Monaco to host first Miracle Bar Pop-Up

The concept of The Miracle Bar was born in 2014 when upon the advice of his mother, owner Greg Boehm…

4 hours ago
  • Creep of the Week

Donald Trump

Well, we made it. We lived through the 2018 midterm election, an election that saw record turnouts. And record voter…

5 hours ago
  • Travel

Pride Journey: Indianapolis

by Joey Amato Indianapolis has always felt like a second home to me. I used to publish a gay magazine…

24 hours ago
  • Local

LDS Church delivers disciplinary notice to ‘Mormon Discussions’ podcaster

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints last week served a former church bishop with a disciplinary notice saying…

1 day ago